Dear Ask Boz,
Do you prefer cake or pie?
- Ben
Wow. Tough one. Both can be delicious in a variety of ways. But a true comparison is not about flavor alone. No, to make this determination we need to explore which one has the “tastier” sayings. Let’s rate the most common phrases associated with these two bakery delights:
- “Easy as pie” vs “A piece of cake.” Since both essentially mean the same thing, this is a tie. Pie 0 – Cake 0
- Historically, we have “Let them eat cake” versus “As American as apple pie.” Since the first is from France, and we defeated France 250 years ago in the war of 1811, pie wins this one. ‘Merica! Pie 1 – Cake 0
- “Pie in the sky” vs “Takes the cake.” The first one is about dreams being out of reach, while the second is about being rewarded for doing something great. We don’t need your negativity, pie! Pie 1 – Cake 1
- “Humble pie” vs “Cakewalk”: Again, we have some pie related negativity. But, like, why is a cakewalk easy? Have you ever thought how gross it would be, walking on cake? Like frosting everywhere, squishy cake chunks squirting out under your feet. Eww! What if you’re barefoot? Or if it rains? Gross. Pie 2 – Cake 1
- “Have your fingers in many pies” vs “Can’t have your cake and eat it too”. The first one is weird. How can I spread my fingers out so I can put them in multiple pies at once? Are they a bunch of tiny pies all kind of close together? But then we have this cake saying, which doesn’t make sense unless you conjugate the pluperfect of the word “have”, carry the one and multiply by three. So, since the first one offers me many pies, which are all mine since I put my dirty fingers in them, and the second one is some kind of “Schrödinger’s Cake” thought experiment where I can either have cake and not eat it, or not have cake and eat it anyways, I have to go with pie here. Pie 3 – Cake 1
So there you have it! Scientific proof that pie is better than cake!
Yours truly,
Ask Boz